Free for a Fee

In a statement released today, UCLA announced that it will restart its former practice of streaming (entire) movies/videos within an accessed controlled online classroom. You can see this announcement here. The news release article contains links to a principals document that outlines the rationale, if you will, UCLA is advancing.

I find the document confusing from a legal standpoint. To me, fair use is tangled in with 110(1), the face-to-face performance exception which is further tangled up with 110(2), the TEACH Act and topped off with the concept of time-shifting (from the Sony case) and the argument that virtual classrooms should be no different than physical classrooms regardless of how the law reads. Favorable pieces of one section of the law are taken out of context and combined with pieces from somewhere else. The idea that the same performance can be in both 110(1) and 110(2) simultaneously is very confusing.

Peggy
more

The content in this post was found at http://chaucer.umuc.edu/blogcip/collectanea/2010/03/ucla_to_start_streaming_entire.html and was not authored by the moderators of freeforafee.com. Clicking the title link will take you to the source of the post.

Some years ago, I was in a meeting with a high IP official of a certain political administration (neither of which will be named here), discussing exceptions to copyright law and trying to make the point that these were critical to the mission of secondary and higher education, which were (even then) cash-strapped. The unnamed official had a simple response to this argument, which ran (in effect) like this:

These days, education is big business, and a big market for copyrighted material. If copyright licenses cost to much, the right answer isn’t to impose costs on copyright owners but to go back to education funders and ask for additional appropriations to cover rights clearances.

Somehow, this line didn’t seem right then, and it doesn’t seem right now. But the argument may be a bit more difficult to counter than some educators believe (or hope). It is, however, important that we prepare to do so, as we gird for a struggle over the future of educational fair use.
more

The content in this post was found at http://chaucer.umuc.edu/blogcip/collectanea/atom.xml and was not authored by the moderators of freeforafee.com. Clicking the title link will take you to the source of the post.